Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Why does my back hurt so much?


Why back pain and neck pain are different than arm or leg pain.

I hear from patients frequently: "I didn't do anything that I remember", "I lifted some things this weekend but nothing out of the ordinary", or "I'm worried that I'm about to break!"

Intense back or neck pain can be very startling--even scary.  When pain appears without a specific incident or accident, it's hard to understand.  Neck, upper back, and lower back pain can feel like you're headed towards paralysis and not able to return to the activities you want to do or even need to do.  But why does neck pain or low back pain seem so much more challenging that wrist or ankle pain?

I suggest we remember that our neck and back muscles are most often controlled by the sub-conscious while our arms & legs are more often controlled by conscious decisions.  You actively choose to move your arm to reach in the fridge, but you probably put little thought into all the back muscles you need to hold your body in front of the fridge.  In that same way, our brains are able to discriminate more clearly what is happening to our elbow, while we have a greater challenge sensing where the pain is coming from in the back.  I am often told: "it hurts everywhere in my neck".  Which is another way of saying: "I can't tell where it's located." 

If you're experiencing neck or back pain, visit a chiropractor or physical therapist whom you trust.  Once a thorough exam has ruled out scary things (which would suggest more immediate or aggressive intervention), you can proceed toward conservative treatments knowing they are likely to help the most and have the least risk.  Conservative manual therapy (including manipulation, soft-tissue treatments, Active Release Techniques, and exercise) works so well because it treats the source of the problem, which is often that muscles, nerves, and ligaments are irritated.  The best way to calm them down is by providing calm, soothing input.  The kind of input that is gentle on the body, feels good, and helps you return to the activities you want to accomplish.

Monday, May 30, 2011

Attitude for Success: Making long term body changes

Last week, Jim came into my office finding it near impossible to walk.  He was supposed to be golfing with family in three days.  He had low back pain that had gotten worse over the past 2 months, a sharpness like a knife that prevented finding any comfortable position.  Fortunately, we were able to show him the exercises that would help his back calm down, and he was able to play 72 holes within 72 hours.  This is not the most amazing part...

...he came back from the trip and asked to learn what he could do to prevent that pain from ever returning.

Eliminating pain is exciting, and patients are--of course--glad to be out of pain.  Preventing future incidents is additionally rewarding.  Because I take much more time per patient than most physicians, I enjoy a unique opportunity to calm fears and educate for the future.  There is often exercises in rehab or activity that will prevent pain from returning in the same way.  I want to highlight the best start towards prevention which is a healthy mental attitude.  In three steps:

1) Loving Curiosity:  An attitude of curiosity and acceptance is crucial for lasting changes.  You must view your problem as a experience you are having, not a fault or failure.  Instead of thinking, "I have horrible posture" or "I am lazy and never exercise", you might ponder, "what get's in the way of me exercising?" or "what type of activity would I like to do?"  Too often we close the door on change by attacking the one we're trying to help: ourselves.

2) Seeking a plan:  Steps toward prevention most often include (a) optimal movement, (b) increased sleep, and (c) healthful diet.  Is there an area you would like more information on?  Do you think you could use an expert opinion on how to move, what to eat, or how to attain more rest?  Ask your physician or friends if they know an expert in that area.  Browse a few blogs and get some simple tips.  You could even comment on this blog and we'll continue the dialogue.  Be encouraged to take small steps, but keep stepping forward.

3) Following through: This is not about willpower.  Repeat that to yourself.  You will not continue activity which you do not truly enjoy.  You cannot force yourself to participate in something you find miserable or undesirable.  Dream of activity you would like to do, imagine how you might feel with appropriate rest, and how delicious healthful food might taste.  By all means, if you find yourself slowing momentum or worse yet, quitting--stop and return to step 1) Loving Curiosity.

You can best help someone you love, equipped with fresh ideas, and continuing to take small steps forward.  Best wishes on seeking the changes you desire!

Thursday, March 17, 2011

Medicine at a Crossroads

The dying art of patient care

When you last went to the doctor, did you feel they tried to listen and explain...or did it feel like he took a guess at which medicine was going to make you better?  Did you feel more like a patient or a customer at a diner?

Our nation is engaged in a potent discussion over medicine, mostly over who is going to pay the bill.  Who gets coverage?  What coverage do we get?  Important questions.  More importantly, who's making these tough decisions?  I believe we're missing a huge issue about what role a doctor plays in our care.  It's like we're at the dealership haggling over price and financing without asking what car we get.  If we end up without a listening expert who will help us make good health choices, what car are we driving?  I believe now more than ever, we need an expert adviser who will help us negotiate questions of surgery, medications, and therapy options.

Psychiatrist Dr. Donald Levin offers an example of the compromises currently demanded by our health care decline.  In a recent interview (http://nyti.ms/fWL7tS), he described how as a result of managed care pressure, he was no longer seeing patients 45 min, with time to listen and solve, but rather 15 min visits to adjust medications.  Dr. Levin reveals, "I had to train myself no to get too interested in their problems."  This change in psychiatry is one of many areas of medicine that have shifted dramatically away from a model of 'listen, diagnose, & teach' to one of 'interject, order tests, & prescribe'.  Most upsetting, this shift is happening despite evidence that quality of care is greatly suffering. 

Dr. Levin's son is pursuing his own career in psychiatry.  Dr. Matthew Levin stated, "I’m concerned that I may be put in a position where I’d be forced to sacrifice patient care to make a living, and I’m hoping to avoid that."  Hoping?!  Well, I'm hoping our nation demands that quality patient care continue to be a ethical mandate for all physicians, not a secondary question to who else in lining their pockets.

The current drive of medicine to produce assembly line results offering an algorithmic response to human health denies value in our uniqueness as individual patients and the dynamic ways in which we respond to care.  We would do well to demand health care that puts the patient first--instead of the insurance companies reimbursement rates or a physician's changing salary.  We're trading a sit down family meal for a drive through hamburger...and paying more for it!  The cost is the declining quality of patient care and higher costs for all.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Truth in Numbers - How risky is chiropractic care?

What the cost of insurance says about the safety of Chiropractic Medicine

Just paid my malpractice insurance bill--whew!  A whole $480 later, I and my patients are protected against any risks of practicing Chiropractic Medicine.  Yes, you read that clearly: 480 dollars...for the whole year.  Many of you pay more than that for car insurance--much, much more.  The insurance company is basically saying that your drive to the grocery store is more risky than all the treatments I have so far provided.  Kind of amazing.

Curious what your other doctors pay for their insurance?  Why not ask one?  In North Carolina, where our rates are often lower than the national average, MDs still pay significantly more than $400.  General internists are often in the $10,000 - $40,000 / year range.  Specialists like Ob/Gyn, cardiac, and surgeons can often range upwards of $250,000 per year.  A quarter of a million dollars for a year's coverage!  Why so expensive--because the insurance companies know that having back surgery is likely 500 times more risky for their bottom line than you choosing a chiropractor.

This is especially important to me to clarify the worries of risk.  There are still some people, and unfortunately, some experts, who are concerned about the risks of seeing a chiropractor.  I recently treated a student-athlete who's team staff warned him that seeing a chiropractor could be dangerous for his back.  It's disappointing to have misinformation create fear.  And that information couldn't be further from the truth.  This patient was back on the field with no pain in 2 visits, treated with both joint manipulation and muscle re-education.

Chiropractors are trained to use neurologic and orthopedic testing as part of a full physical exam, in the same way that every physician should, to rule out patients who may be at risk from specific treatments.  Manipulation is only one technique we use at our office.  We use soft-tissue treatments, including functional rehabilitation and Active Release Techniques more frequently to get the fastest and best results with little risk.  Next time you think of your car insurance, you might remember how safe and effective chiropractic care can be.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Numbness in the fingers: one patient's story

Gail was in a bad car accident 8 weeks ago--thank goodness she's alright.  She's almost back to normal except for the burning in her fingers on both hands and soreness in her forearms.  Fortunately, a friend told her about our office--especially how we expect results within a few visits.  I took over 40 minutes listening to her story, and it surprised me how clearly she described the moment of injury.  She said that the airbag came out so fast, it ripped her hands from the wheel before she could let go.  I pondered what I would ask my students about this case: "which muscle begins in the forearm, crosses the wrist, attaches to the fingers, and would explain burning in the fingers and pain in the forearm?"  Any guesses??  ...

Flexor digitorum profundus/superficialis indeed!  Sounds like a likely scenario for the symptoms she describes.  What does this mean?  It means Gail's story matches her continued symptoms, and it's likely something that can be treated and resolved quickly.  It means that following a thorough exam (to make sure we're not jumping to conclusions but evaluating the facts), we can gently treat these muscles in the palm side of her forearm and look for quick relief and comfort.




Happier ever after?  Yes.  But could have been much smoother.  Another chiropractor had told her that she had whiplash in her neck and that's what caused her pain.  He adjusted her neck for 6 weeks without improvement to her pain.  He told Gail she needed to stick with his program, and she would be better in a few months.  Disappointing!  She asked her primary care MD, and he prescribed her pain killers and told her to return if it didn't get better.  I wish he had known about the care we could provide.  I'm most glad that Gail is feeling better and able to use her hands without burning or pain.

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Should I worry over my back x-ray? The diagnosis sounds scary!

Patients often ask great questions with very personal feelings.  What I mean is that history and math professors may get great questions but a student is less anxious over what the answer might be.  One of the best parts of being a doctor is explaining something to a patient about their body.  It can mean  encouragement from great fear to relief or bringing comfort and illumination to a challenging outlook of injury.  We care about what is happening to our body.

A patient recently told me: "I had a MRI last week and got the results today. I have a herniated disk, and arthritis.  I am being referred to a specialist. I guess what is your take on both of those? I was in such shock when they told me the news I couldnt comprehend anything they were saying."

I've spoken about the value of xrays before (http://bit.ly/b0hhcX), and I would speak of MRI testing similarly.  These tests are valuable tools when utilized to support an overall clinical picture.  They are often misleading and unhelpful tools for pain.  As the New York Times recently offered, "magnetic resonance imaging seldom sheds light -- indeed, in many studies the scans have picked up spinal abnormalities in many people who have never reported back pain" (http://nyti.ms/eENwWu). Unfortunately, many physicians will see an MRI report with degenerative changes and refer to a specialist for significant interventions (surgery, narcotic medications, injections) when prevention would be more productive to the patient.

Doctors are often driven to interventions while patients would more often benefit from preventions or restorative care.  Our health care system does not incentivize preventative medicine nor is there a reward for saving patient's time and money.  Our system promotes number and frequency of treatments, the costlier to the patient, the better for the industry.  What would happen if a doctor was paid from the overall health of their patients or how much activity the patients were able to enjoy in a year?  What a dream that might be!

When a patient hears "degenerative disc disease", "arthritis", "herniated discs", "misalignment", "subluxations", and other less helpful, common diagnoses, I would encourage a response of "what treatment is best for my body?".  A patient needs to ask, "What is most likely to restore my ability to move and live?".  The momentum of research indicates for low back pain: surgery, drugs, and bed rest are least likely to help while physical therapy, soft-tissue therapy, chiropractic techniques, and rehabilitative exercises are far more productive, safer, and less costly.

In meeting the reality of our system today, patients cannot change economic forces behind surgery and pharmaceutical medicine, but each can ask their physician, "what is the safest and most productive option for my body?"

Sunday, October 17, 2010

Value of a physical exam

The physical exam is a dying art in medicine.  Patients know this; you may have waited longer in the waiting room or filling out forms than your doctor took to examine your condition.  There is much evidence to the value of a doctor taking the time to fully examine your body and talk with you to discover what the best course of treatment might be.

A recent article: http://nyti.ms/aGv0m4, from the New York Times, which shares Dr. Verghese's work at Stanford medical school.  As a professor, I encourage my students to spend time and effort with a thoughtful history--making a great effort to listen to a patient.  A proper exam requires time not just for talking but also for inspection, palpation, range of motion, orthopedic, and neurologic testing.  'Time' is the key.  It is not possible to consider most conditions in 20 minutes.


In practice, at Tri-Synergy Chiropractic, we reserve 90 minutes for new patient visits.  We've found the best care we can offer takes between 60-90 minutes.  We average 2-3 visits per patient with fully successful outcomes because we take the time to listen to a patient, ask key questions, and examine their body before we conclude how we might help.

The pressure other physicians feel to finish a pt visit in 15-20 minutes leads to higher use of MRI, xray, and other expensive testing, without improved healing outcomes.  This also leads to a quick prescription mentality, that encourages patients to "take two of pills and call me in a week" instead of assessing the underlying problem.  There is a great value in technology, but it will never replace the importance of a physician listening and touching their patient.